Bay Harbor Islands Homes for Sale under $5M

151 listings
1176 97th ST # 501, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
Newly Listed

Condo for Sale

$2,300,000

2 bd · 3 ba · 1,849 sqft

1176 97th ST # 501, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

The Well

9400 W Bay Harbor Dr # 101, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
76 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$2,250,000

4 bd · 5 ba · 2,483 sqft

9400 W Bay Harbor Dr # 101, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

RIVER BAY HARBOR

1176 97th St # 608, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
25 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$2,225,000

2 bd · 3 ba · 1,267 sqft

1176 97th St # 608, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

THE WELL BAY HARBOR

1125 97th St # 501, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
17 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$2,150,000

2 bd · 3 ba · 2,123 sqft

1125 97th St # 501, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

MILA Bay Harbor Islands

9901 W Bay Harbor Dr # 503, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
12 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$2,050,000

3 bd · 4 ba · 1,662 sqft

9901 W Bay Harbor Dr # 503, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

Alana

9940 W Bay Harbor Dr # 7H-S, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
105 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$1,999,999

3 bd · 3 ba · 1,834 sqft

9940 W Bay Harbor Dr # 7H-S, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

Kai at Bay Harbor

9900 W Bay Harbor Dr # 704, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
178 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$1,995,000

2 bd · 3 ba ·

9900 W Bay Harbor Dr # 704, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

9900 West

1135 103rd St # 203, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
Newly Listed

Condo for Sale

$1,980,000

3 bd · 4 ba · 2,333 sqft

1135 103rd St # 203, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

Onda Residences

1135 103rd # 307, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
178 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$1,900,000

2 bd · 3 ba ·

1135 103rd # 307, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

Onda Residences

9940 W Bay Harbor Dr # 3G-N, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
214 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$1,880,000

3 bd · 3 ba · 1,882 sqft

9940 W Bay Harbor Dr # 3G-N, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

KAI AT BAY HARBOR

1150 101st St # PH702, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
65 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$1,850,000

4 bd · 3 ba · 1,972 sqft

1150 101st St # PH702, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

One Bay Harbor

1000 99th St # 14, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
798 Days on Market

Townhome for Sale

$1,750,000

4 bd · 5 ba · 2,519 sqft

1000 99th St # 14, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

Palm Villas

9901 W Bay Harbor Dr # 403, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
419 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$1,739,900

3 bd · 4 ba · 1,662 sqft

9901 W Bay Harbor Dr # 403, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

Alana Bay Harbor

9221 E Bay Harbor Dr # 309, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
155 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$1,690,000

2 bd · 3 ba · 1,329 sqft

9221 E Bay Harbor Dr # 309, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

BAY HARBOR ISLAND

9901 W Bay Harbor Dr # 303, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
40 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$1,639,900

3 bd · 4 ba · 1,662 sqft

9901 W Bay Harbor Dr # 303, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

Alana Bay Harbor

9261 E Bay Harbor Dr # 704, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
80 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$1,599,000

2 bd · 3 ba · 1,958 sqft

9261 E Bay Harbor Dr # 704, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

Ivory Residende

1176 97th Street # 302, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
97 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$1,599,000

1 bd · 2 ba · 1,150 sqft

1176 97th Street # 302, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

The Well Bay Harbor

9221 E Bay Harbor Drive # 212, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
Newly Listed

Condo for Sale

$1,579,999

2 bd · 3 ba · 1,420 sqft

9221 E Bay Harbor Drive # 212, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

LA BAIA BAY HARBOR ISLAND

1176 97th st # 707, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
101 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$1,499,000

1 bd · 2 ba ·

1176 97th st # 707, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

THE WELL BAY HARBOR

9221 E Bay Harbor Drive # 412, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
138 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$1,499,000

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,420 sqft

9221 E Bay Harbor Drive # 412, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

La Baia South Tower

1170 101st St # 601, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
Newly Listed

Condo for Sale

$1,400,000

2 bd · 3 ba · 1,828 sqft

1170 101st St # 601, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

Pearl House

1150 101st St # 701, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
2031 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$1,390,000

3 bd · 3 ba · 1,492 sqft

1150 101st St # 701, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

ONE BAY HARBOR CONDO

9901 W Bay Harbor Dr # 506, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
Newly Listed

Condo for Sale

$1,350,000

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,366 sqft

9901 W Bay Harbor Dr # 506, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

Alana Condo

9940 W Bay Harbor Dr # 6C-N, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154
11 Days on Market

Condo for Sale

$1,299,000

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,276 sqft

9940 W Bay Harbor Dr # 6C-N, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154

Kai Bay Harbor

Talk to a local agent

Looking at Bay Harbor Islands Homes for Sale under $5M?

Tell us what you're after — we'll send matching homes, off-market options and recent sales, and set up private showings.

Matthew Gromadzki, Real Estate Broker
Matthew Gromadzki
Real Estate Broker
(786) 370-8570
Send a message

We reply the same day.

By submitting you agree to be contacted about your inquiry. No spam, ever.

Live MLS inventory in Bay Harbor Islands, updated continuously. Florida Lux Real Estate currently tracks 151 active listings here. MLS inventory updated October 29, 2026.

Homes for Sale under $5M in Bay Harbor Islands: What to Know Before You Search

Bay Harbor Islands is a low-rise town spread across two islands in Biscayne Bay, one bridge from Bal Harbour Shops. Height-limited streets blend mid-century co-ops with the densest run of boutique bayfront new construction in South Florida, much of it offering private dockage, and the A-rated K-8 school is a real draw.

Setting the ceiling at $5.0M turns Bay Harbor Islands into a value hunt — and the value tends to hide in specific corners: an older building whose fees undersell its address, a property type the market keeps overlooking, a block just off the prime grid. Known for boutique bayfront buildings and an A-rated school, a bridge from Bal Harbour, Bay Harbor Islands always has an under-the-radar pocket, and this page keeps every listing beneath the cap in one place so none of it slips past you.

Bay Harbor Islands Market Snapshot

136
Homes sold, last 12 months
$830K
Median sale price
116 days
Median time on market

Frequently Asked Questions

What can I realistically buy in Bay Harbor Islands under $5.0M?

The honest inventory is right here, updated continuously, and the mix shifts month to month. As a rule of thumb condos stretch a capped budget furthest, townhomes buy the most space, and houses under a ceiling trade quickest. We'll tell you candidly which listings are priced low for a reason.

What costs sit beyond the price in Bay Harbor Islands?

Budget association dues on condos and townhomes, insurance that shifts with roof age and flood zone, and buyer closing costs of roughly two to three percent. We build a true monthly-cost sheet for any listing before you offer, so your ceiling still holds after closing.

How do I arrange a showing in Bay Harbor Islands?

Each listing on this page carries an inquiry form that goes straight to our brokerage — or reach us at +1 786-370-8570. We schedule private tours to fit your calendar and run live video walkthroughs for buyers relocating from out of state, with no obligation attached.

Discover Your Perfect Home

Homes for Sale under $5M in Nearby Cities
Select Property Type
Bay Harbor Islands Condos for Sale by Type & Price
Bedroom Size Homes in Bay Harbor Islands
Homes by Price in Bay Harbor Islands
Lifestyle & New in Bay Harbor Islands
Rentals in Bay Harbor Islands
Homes Nearby Bay Harbor Islands: Neighborhoods
Homes Nearby Bay Harbor Islands: Cities
Homes Nearby Bay Harbor Islands: ZIP Codes